Estate of Robert E. Cartwright, Deceased, Dorothy G. Cartwright, Executrix - Page 12

                                       - 12 -                                         

          fees earned on cases decedent brought to CSB, and ensured that              
          decedent’s widow would receive money promptly after decedent                
          died.                                                                       
               The 1973 agreement stated that a deceased shareholder's                
          estate would be repaid the amount the shareholder paid for CSB              
          stock, and would be paid any earned but unpaid dividends, 25                
          percent of the net fees CSB received on cases or from business              
          clients the shareholder brought to CSB, and certain other                   
          amounts.  The 1988 amendment stated that the insurance payment              
          was both for decedent's stock and for claims for fees earned on             
          cases decedent brought to CSB.                                              
               Petitioner argues that the 1988 amendment was a buy-sell               
          agreement that fixed the redemption price of decedent’s CSB stock           
          at $5 million.  Petitioner also argues that the parties used the            
          value of CSB’s work in process only to measure the payment for              
          decedent’s interest in CSB, and that doing so does not convert              
          any of that payment to compensation.                                        
               We disagree.  Petitioner's argument overlooks the plain                
          language of the 1988 amendment.  The 1988 amendment plainly                 
          requires CSB to use the insurance proceeds to buy “all of * * *             
          [decedent’s] stock in the Corporation together with any claim to            
          any cases or work in process that may otherwise be made on behalf           
          of * * * [decedent]."  The 1988 amendment also fixed the value of           
          “said stock and claim in said cases and work in process” as the             





Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011