Philippe and Nadine Grelsamer - Page 44

                                       - 44 -                                         
          professional money manager.  Beginning in the early 1970's,                 
          petitioners combined their talents and together they began                  
          organizing and syndicating oil drilling ventures.  Morgan                   
          estimated that they drilled about 10 to 15 wells a year in the              
          mid to late 1970's.  Because of their investment acumen and                 
          thorough, cautious approach, petitioners' oil drilling ventures             
          yielded a 90- to 95-percent success rate.  Certainly petitioners            
          possessed the engineering and financial intellect, skills,                  
          experience, and resources to investigate properly the viability             
          of the Plastics Recycling transactions either themselves or by              
          employing an independent, qualified expert.                                 
               Petitioners claim that they relied on Becker for the bona              
          fides and viability of the Partnership transactions.  Yet                   
          Becker's expertise was in taxation, not plastics materials or               
          plastics recycling, and his investigation and analysis of the               
          Plastics Recycling transactions reflected this circumstance.                
          Petitioners knew that Becker was not an engineer or expert in               
          plastics materials or plastics recycling.  Grelsamer even                   
          testified that because Becker was not an engineer his visit to PI           
          could not have meant much to him and that Grelsamer was sure that           
          it did not.  Moreover, Becker testified that he was very careful            
          not to mislead any of his clients regarding the particulars of              
          his investigation.  As he put it:  "I don't recall saying to a              
          client I did due diligence * * * [Rather,] I told [my clients]              






Page:  Previous  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  49  50  51  52  53  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011