Lear Eye Clinic, Ltd., et al. - Page 19

                                                   19                                                     
            be credited as years of service for the employer.  Section 414(a)                             
            provides:                                                                                     
                  SEC. 414. DEFINITIONS AND SPECIAL RULES.                                                
                        (a)  Service for Predecessor Employer.--For                                       
                  purposes of this part--                                                                 
                               (1) in any case in which the employer                                      
                        maintains a plan of a predecessor employer,                                       
                        service for such predecessor shall be treated                                     
                        as service for the employer, and                                                  
                               (2) in any case in which the employer                                      
                        maintains a plan which is not the plan                                            
                        maintained by a predecessor employer, service                                     
                        for such predecessor shall, to the extent                                         
                        provided in regulations prescribed by the                                         
                        Secretary, be treated as service for the                                          
                        employer.                                                                         
            No regulations have been issued pursuant to section 414(a)(2).                                
                  The cases before us do not involve the situation in section                             
            414(a)(1), in which the employer maintains a plan of a                                        
            predecessor employer.  Petitioners apparently do not ask us to                                
            interpret section 414(a)(2) in their favor, and we doubt such a                               
            request would prove beneficial.  See Carver v. Westinghouse                                   
            Hanford Co., 951 F.2d 1083, 1088 (9th Cir. 1991); Phillips v.                                 
            Amoco Oil Co., 799 F.2d 1464, 1470-1471 (11th Cir. 1986)                                      
            (interpreting the ERISA counterpart to section 414(a)(2) and                                  
            concluding that Congress intended to leave to the Secretary of                                
            the Treasury the question of whether to require such service with                             
            a predecessor employer be taken into account).  Petitioners                                   
            instead argue that, in the absence of regulations under section                               
            414(a)(2), the plan sponsor or the plan administrator had the                                 




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011