Medieval Attractions N.V - Page 116

                                       - 63 -                                         
               With regard to the deduction for the amortization expense,             
          C&L noted that, for the deduction to be taken, the transferee of            
          a franchise must also be conducting a trade or business.  It                
          explained that the trade or business requirement allows                     
          deductions for expenses incurred only when business operations              
          commence and activities for which the trade or business was                 
          formed are performed.  C&L stated that there was an issue as to             
          whether or not a trade or business existed with respect to MCI              
          and GCI/SDCI because the actual operations of the castles would             
          not commence for at least a year.                                           
               C&L addressed a resolution for both issues and stated:                 
               However, if we assume that both MC [MCI] and GC                        
               [GCI/SDCI] can be operated as divisions of MDT instead                 
               of separate subsidiaries, an argument can be made for                  
               amortizing the franchise rights before the commencement                
               of operations at MC and GC.  It can be argued that MDT                 
               acquired the additional franchise rights in order to                   
               expand into other territories and as such the                          
               amortization of the additional franchise rights are                    
               "ordinary and necessary" expansion costs incurred by an                
               ongoing business enterprise in "carrying on a trade or                 
               business."                                                             
          C&L concluded that “there appears to be relatively strong support           
          for deducting pre-operating expenses at MC [MCI] and GC [GCI] and           
          amortizing the franchise rights for the Glendale and Meadowlands            
          sites as long as both castles are operated as divisions of MDT,             
          not as separate subsidiaries.”  C&L recommended a number of                 
          actions, which included:                                                    
               Operate the two additional castles as divisions of MDT                 
               and delay equity contributions to MC [MCI] and GC [GCI]                
               until after the operation commences at each location.                  




Page:  Previous  53  54  55  56  57  58  59  60  61  62  63  64  65  66  67  68  69  70  71  72  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011