David Rothner and Nancy J. Rothner - Page 4

                                        - 4 -                                         
          involved 50 futures contracts, and the trades of his brokerage              
          association also involved a larger number of futures contracts              
          than were customary for others in the pit.  Petitioner's                    
          association accounted for approximately one-third of the trading            
          volume in Eurodollar futures contracts on the CME.                          
               The CME maintains a written set of rules and regulations               
          specifying the rights and obligations of membership in the CME              
          and governing trading through its facilities.  As a condition of            
          membership in the CME, a member must agree to abide by its rules.           
          Except as otherwise provided by Federal law, the rights and                 
          obligations of CME members arise pursuant to contract law, rather           
          than statute, government regulation, or tort.  During May 1987,             
          the CME adopted new rules and amended existing ones that imposed,           
          inter alia, a limitation on the percentage of trades that one               
          member of a brokerage association could execute with members of             
          the same association and specified sanctions for violations of              
          those rules.  Those rules provide that petitioner could execute             
          no more than 25 percent of his trades with other members of his             
          brokerage association.  There had been no limit on the amount of            
          trading petitioner could conduct with the other members of his              
          association prior to the adoption of those rules.  The limit                
          imposed by the CME rule made it harder for petitioner to fill               
          customer orders.  In an attempt to avoid exceeding the limitation           
          on trading with the other members of his association, petitioner            
          would execute trades with them through Brian Elliott, a CME                 




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011