The Charles Schwab Corporation and Includable Subsidiaries - Page 20

                                           - 20 -                                            
          commission.  See Central Cuba Sugar Co. v. Commissioner, supra at                  
          217-218 (holding that sales commission expenses were deductible                    
          in the year the taxpayer entered the contract for sale even                        
          though they were not payable until delivery, and even though the                   
          commission expenses were subject to adjustment in accordance with                  
          final weighing before shipment and forfeiture if the contract                      
          were not carried out).                                                             
                Petitioner argues that unlike full-commission securities                     
          brokers who engage in a full range of activities, such as                          
          research and portfolio management, the functions performed by                      
          petitioner between the trade and settlement dates represent a                      
          substantial percentage of the services provided by petitioner to                   
          its brokerage customers.  According to petitioner, the commission                  
          income received by petitioner does not represent payment for                       
          investment advice or other pretrade services, but rather is a fee                  
          for the specific services of executing the transaction and                         
          handling the mechanics of the transfer of title and delivery on                    
          the settlement date.  Therefore, petitioner argues, even if the                    
          posttrade activities conducted by a full-commission broker are                     
          considered ministerial, they cannot be considered ministerial                      
          when performed by a discount broker such as petitioner.                            
                While we appreciate the differences in the services provided                 
          by full-commission and discount brokers, we cannot agree that                      
          ministerial acts that constitute conditions subsequent to a                        
          customer’s obligation to pay commissions are converted to                          




Page:  Previous  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011