Stanley I. Caplan - Page 3

                                                 - 3 -                                                   
            that petitioner is not entitled to file a joint return, because                              
            such an election would be untimely.  At the time of trial,                                   
            petitioner and his wife had not filed a joint return.                                        
                  Petitioner's request is, essentially, a request for a                                  
            declaratory judgment that he is entitled to file a joint return                              
            in the future.  See 22A Am. Jur. 2d, Declaratory Judgments, sec.                             
            1, at 670 (1988) (stating that a declaratory judgment is a                                   
            judgment declaring the rights and duties, or the status, of the                              
            parties in advance of a planned act or event and citing numerous                             
            cases).  The Tax Court, with the exception of certain instances                              
            specifically prescribed by statute, does not possess jurisdiction                            
            over requests for declaratory judgment.  See secs. 7428 (relating                            
            to qualification of organizations as tax-exempt), 7476 (relating                             
            to qualification of certain retirement plans), 7478 (relating to                             
            the tax status of municipal bonds); Rules 13(a),(b) and 210(c).                              
            Petitioner's request does not fall within any statute conferring                             
            jurisdiction upon this Court.  As a result, we conclude that we                              
            lack jurisdiction to decide whether petitioner may, in the                                   
            future, file a joint return.  We note, however, that section                                 
            6013(b)(2)(C) provides that a taxpayer may not make an election                              
            to file a joint return after either spouse files a timely                                    
            petition with this Court.                                                                    
                  All other arguments made by the parties are either                                     
            irrelevant or without merit.                                                                 






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011