S.K. Johnston, III and Julie N. Boyle f.k.a. Julie N. Johnston, et al. - Page 36

                                               - 36 -                                                 

            even though losses or only occasional small profits are actually                          
            generated.  Sec. 1.183-2(b)(7), Income Tax Regs.                                          
                  Respondent focuses on the fact that Gillian Johnston grew up                        
            training and racing horses, enjoys steeplechase training, and                             
            still loves to ride.  Thus, respondent contends that most of her                          
            activities in connection with GJ Stables were for pleasure and                            
            recreation rather than for business.  We disagree.  First, we                             
            note that Gillian Johnston has not done any steeplechase racing                           
            in this country, and she employs professional jockeys to ride the                         
            stable's horses in all races.  Moreover, if GJ was actually a                             
            hobby, Gillian Johnston most likely would have hired others to                            
            perform the dirty tasks associated with running a stable.                                 
            However, in an effort to reduce costs, she performed these                                
            arduous tasks herself, including shoveling horse manure.                                  
                  Finally, in passing we note that the tax law does not                               
            prohibit an individual from enjoying his or her work.  See Cole                           
            v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 1992-51 (personal pleasure derived                            
            from operating a pecan farm did not indicate lack of profit                               
            motive).                                                                                  
                  Thus, based on the entire record, we hold that GJ Stables                           
            was an activity engaged in for profit.  Accordingly, petitioners                          
            may deduct their related losses sustained during the years in                             
            issue.                                                                                    
            Issue 5. Whether $1,131,438 Was the Fair Market Value of a                                
            Conservation Easement Encumbering the Flying H Ranch, Donated By                          
            Petitioners to the Nature Conservancy During 1989                                         



Page:  Previous  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011