Joao Montoro and Neuza Paula - Page 14

                                         14                                           
                                       OPINION                                        
          A.   Admissibility of Exhibits AG and AH                                    
               Three days before the trial in this case, respondent's                 
          counsel found in the files for this case a currency transaction             
          report (Exhibit AG) and a criminal referral report prepared by              
          the NCNB National Bank of North Carolina (Exhibit AH) and sent to           
          the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency.  Respondent's                
          counsel had seen these documents before, but had not thought that           
          they were significant.  On the day before the trial, respondent's           
          counsel called petitioners' counsel and told him that respondent            
          might call Rose Wiseman (Wiseman), an administrative assistant at           
          NationsBank in Raleigh, as a rebuttal witness.  Respondent had              
          not listed Wiseman as a witness.  Respondent's counsel gave him             
          Wiseman's name and telephone number, but did not give him a copy            
          of Exhibits AG and AH.  Petitioners' counsel did not contact                
          Wiseman.                                                                    
               At trial, petitioner-husband testified that he made three              
          cash deposits totaling $28,500 on April 4, 1991, but that he did            
          not remember the denominations of the currency he deposited.                
          Respondent called Wiseman to impeach his testimony.  During                 
          Wiseman's testimony, respondent offered Exhibits AG and AH into             
          evidence.  Exhibit AG reports that John M. Paula made a $28,500             
          cash deposit on April 4, 1991, and that the deposit was made to             
          three accounts and consisted of $28,500 in $100 bills and larger.           






Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011