Ivor F. and Debra A. Benci-Woodward, et al. - Page 14

                                       - 14 -                                         
          amount of $900,000, the taxpayer receiving a net of $525,000                
          after attorney's fees and costs.  On remand, the Court of Appeals           
          provided the Tax Court with instructions on possible methods of             
          valuing the punitive damage portion of the settlement, stating              
          that "It is appropriate for the case to be remanded to the Tax              
          Court to permit a determination as to what portion of the                   
          $900,000 gross amount in settlement (reduced to $525,000 net) was           
          attributable to punitive damages."  Id. at 592.  (Emphasis                  
          added).  The Court of Appeals does not explain its reason for               
          reducing the $900,000 gross amount to the $525,000 net amount,              
          before the directed allocation between punitive and compensatory            
          damages.                                                                    
               With the exception of Cotnam v. Commissioner, supra, and               
          Davis v. Commissioner, supra (which, as noted, followed Cotnam              
          under the Golsen rule), courts, when directly confronted with the           
          question, have uniformly rejected the contention that taxpayers             
          may exclude the amount of their legal fees and costs from gross             
          income in cases such as the one before us.  Since the courts in             
          the 3 cases cited by petitioners were not so confronted, and                
          therefore did not have the occasion to focus directly on the                
          issue, we decline to accept those cases as precedent for the                
          proposition that petitioners' gross income is to be determined              
          net of their attorney's fees (and costs).  For examples of recent           







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011