Denson C. and Linda C. Brumley - Page 5

                                        - 5 -                                         

          income as an independent insurance agent, the effect of which, if           
          determined to be deductible, would reduce her self-employment               
          income and the resulting self-employment tax.  It was at this               
          point that respondent orally moved for a motion for entry of                
          decision.                                                                   
               We deal first with the question of whether we should allow             
          petitioners to raise for the first time, on the date set for                
          trial, the issue regarding their entitlement to deduct certain              
          business expenses in computing net income subject to self-                  
          employment tax.  We must look at the pleadings to see if this               
          issue is, indeed, a new issue, and, if it is, consider whether              
          trying this new issue places respondent at an unfair                        
          disadvantage.                                                               
               Petitioners argue that the issue of petitioners’ entitlement           
          to business deductions is not a new issue because their petition            
          implicitly raises the issue since they have contested the whole             
          amount of the deficiency.  Therefore, petitioners contend that              
          respondent had knowledge of the issue and has not been placed at            
          a disadvantage.  Petitioners further assert that even if we find            
          that this is a new issue, they should be permitted to amend the             
          petition and raise the issue.  Respondent strongly objects to               
          petitioners’ attempt to raise this issue contending that it is a            
          new issue raised for the first time on the day of the trial.  We            
          believe respondent’s objection to be well taken.                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011