David Dobrich and Naomi Dobrich - Page 5

                                        - 5 -                                         

          that the transactions in question were taxable, alternatively,              
          for 1989 or 1990.  We decided that 1989 was the year in which the           
          income was to be included, and no computation under Rule 155 was            
          required for 1990 because of our understanding that petitioners             
          would have no deficiency or overpayment for the 1990 year.                  
          Petitioners, however, proffered a computation for entry of                  
          decision for 1990 reflecting a $20,831 overpayment, which they              
          claim is attributable to additional depreciation that they could            
          have claimed on the acquired properties on the premise that they            
          were purchased, rather than exchanged.  Petitioners point out               
          that they were permitted to amend their petition for the 1990               
          year to claim $75,012 of additional depreciation.  Respondent, in           
          turn, answered petitioners' allegation in the amendment to the              
          1990 petition by admitting that petitioners would be entitled to            
          additional depreciation if the Court determines that "the                   
          transaction is taxable in 1990".  Respondent, however, denied,              
          for lack of sufficient information, that petitioners were                   
          entitled to the amount they had alleged.  Petitioners also                  
          contend that we held that the period for assessment would be open           
          for the 1990 year due to our finding of fraud for 1990.  Under              
          these circumstances, petitioners seek an overpayment for 1990,              
          rather than a "no deficiency, no overpayment" decision.                     
               We find that petitioners are not entitled to an overpayment            
          for their 1990 taxable year.  Their amended petition for 1990               





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011