Linda Evans and Estate of Robert C. Evans, Jr., Deceased, Linda Evans, Executrix - Page 9

                                        - 9 -                                         

          the facts and circumstances of this case, it would be inequitable           
          to hold her liable for the deficiency attributable to the                   
          understatement.  Sec. 6013(e)(1); Reser v. Commissioner, 112 F.3d           
          1258, 1267 (5th Cir. 1997), affg. in part and revg. in part T.C.            
          Memo. 1995-572; United States v. Shanbaum, 10 F.3d 305, 314                 
          (5th Cir. 1994); Estate of Krock v. Commissioner, 93 T.C. 672,              
          676 (1989).  Ms. Evans' failure to satisfy any one of these                 
          elements precludes "innocent spouse" relief.  Reser v.                      
          Commissioner, supra at 1263; United States v. Shanbaum, supra at            
          315; Estate of Krock v. Commissioner, supra at 677.                         
               With respect to each of the subject years, we agree with               
          Ms. Evans that she meets the first requirement for innocent                 
          spouse relief; i.e., the filing of a joint return.  We part                 
          company with her, however, when we turn to the other                        
          requirements.  With respect to the deduction issue in each of the           
          subject years,4 we are unable to find a substantial                         
          understatement of tax.  A substantial understatement would be               
          present if the tax in dispute exceeded an amount based on                   
          Ms. Evans' adjusted gross income for 1995.  Sec. 6013(e)(3) and             
          (4).  We do not know Ms. Evans' gross income for 1995.  Although            
          she asks the Court in her reply brief to reopen the record to               

               4 Ms. Evans asks the Court in her brief to consider this               
          issue to be an unreported income issue.  We decline to do so.               
          Petitioners did not fail to report the income from oil and gas              
          royalties.  They included it on their Forms 1040, and they                  
          claimed a deduction with respect thereto.                                   




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011