Salvador A. and Kathleen M. Gaudiano - Page 10

                                       - 10 -                                         

          title, and interest in and to the equipment to Black Mountain.              
          Respondent argues that there is no evidence that legal title was            
          actually transferred to Black Mountain and points out that no               
          bill of sale was given to Black Mountain.                                   
               The parties to the agreement designated that title passed              
          with the signing of the agreement, and under Kentucky law, the              
          parties' designation controls.  We conclude that legal title                
          passed to Black Mountain on the execution of the agreement.                 
                    2.  How the Parties Treated the Transaction                       
               Four A recorded the transaction as a sale in its bankruptcy            
          filings and ceased taking depreciation deductions related to the            
          equipment after executing the agreement.  Respondent argues that            
          Black Mountain treated the transaction as a lease and relies on             
          the testimony of William Phipps, president of Black Mountain, for           
          this proposition.  Mr. Phipps testified that the transaction was            
          a "lease purchase" and not a sale.  However, during cross-                  
          examination, Mr. Phipps admitted that he did not know the                   
          difference between a lease purchase and a sale agreement and that           
          the purpose in executing the note was to gain ownership of the              
          equipment.  Mr. Phipps also conceded that his partner, Mr.                  
          Donovan, did most of the negotiating with Four A regarding the              
          equipment.                                                                  
               We find that the parties to the agreement treated the                  
          transaction as a sale.                                                      





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011