Craig M. and Rebecca Maxwell - Page 5

                                                - 5 -                                                   
            within the 2 years preceding the claim for refund.  Sec.                                    
            6511(b)(2)(B).  Section 6511(a) states that a claim for refund                              
            generally must be made within 3 years from the time the return                              
            was filed or if no return was filed by the taxpayer, within 2                               
            years from the time the tax was paid.                                                       
                  We apply the established law on the refund of overpayments                            
            to the stipulated amounts shown in the chart above.  The withheld                           
            amounts were deemed withheld on April 15 of the filing years,                               
            sec. 6513(a) and (b)(1), and, when respondent issued petitioners                            
            the notices of deficiency, petitioners had not yet filed their                              
            returns.  Thus, petitioners are limited to a refund of only the                             
            amounts that they paid during the 2-year period prior to the time                           
            that the notices of deficiency were issued.  Commissioner v.                                
            Lundy, supra.  Because petitioners paid none of the disputed                                
            amounts within this 2-year period, we hold that they are not                                
            entitled to a refund of any of these amounts.                                               
                  In reaching our holdings herein, we have considered all                               
            arguments made by petitioners for contrary holdings and, to the                             
            extent not discussed above, find them to be irrelevant or without                           
            merit.                                                                                      
                  To reflect the foregoing,                                                             
                                                             Decision will be entered                   
                                                       stating that there is no                         
                                                       deficiency or additions to tax                   
                                                       for any of the subject years.                    




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  

Last modified: May 25, 2011