Estate of Emanuel Trompeter, Deceased, Robin Carol Trompeter Gonzalez and Janet Ilene Trompeter Polacheck, Co-Executors - Page 16

                                       - 16 -                                         

          taxpayer obeyed the regulation, waited until the event occurred,            
          and sought the promised relief at an appropriate time in the                
          instant Tax Court proceeding.                                               
               In United States v. Olympic Radio & Television, 349 U.S.               
          232, 236 (1955), the Supreme Court directed that “We can only               
          take the Code as we find it and give it as great an internal                
          symmetry and consistency as its words permit.”  Thus, if the                
          phrase “tax required to be shown on a return” were to be                    
          interpreted in a temporal sense in section 6663(a), then it ought           
          to have the same meaning wherever it appears.  This means that it           
          would have the same meaning where it appears in section 6662(a),            
          and would have the same impact on those of the section 6662                 
          additions that apply to the estate tax.                                     
               Respondent’s contentions in the instant case might well lead           
          prudent executors to load up estate tax returns with speculative            
          deductions in order to satisfy this newly proclaimed requirement,           
          that only items claimed on the estate tax return may be taken               
          into account in determining the base for additions to tax under             
          sections 6662 and 6663.                                                     
               Thus, respondent’s contentions in the instant case appear to           
          conflict with Treasury regulations and may well complicate the              
          practical administration of the estate tax laws.                            
                              II.  Legislative History                                
               The majority opinion explains that the phrase “tax required            
          to be shown on a return” has a clear classification meaning in              



Page:  Previous  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011