Gideon L. and Corazon P. Medina - Page 10

                                       - 10 -                                         

          IV. Value of the Use of Loan Proceeds                                       
               Petitioners paid no interest on the loan.  As a result, the            
          "amount involved" is the fair market value of the use of the loan           
          proceeds (i.e., as reflected by the interest rate). Petitioners             
          contend that the loan violates Michigan's usury laws, which                 
          prevent a lender from recovering any interest on loans that                 
          provide for interest at a rate that exceeds 7 percent.  See Mich.           
          Comp. Laws Ann. sec. 438.31 and .32 (1978).  Petitioners further            
          contend that the fair market value of the use of the loan                   
          proceeds is zero.  Respondent contends that the Court should                
          conclude that the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974           
          (ERISA), Pub. L. 93-406, 88 Stat. 829, preempts Michigan's usury            
          laws and that the "amount involved" should be calculated using a            
          10.5-percent interest rate.                                                 
               We reject petitioners' contentions.  Petitioners contend               
          that the fair market value of the use of the loan proceeds equals           
          what a third-party buyer of the usurious loan would assign to the           
          loan's stated interest.  This value should be based, however, on            
          a hypothetical loan between a willing lender and a willing                  
          borrower rather than a hypothetical sale of the loan to a third-            
          party buyer.                                                                
               We agree with respondent that the fair market interest rate            
          is 10.5 percent, but we reject his reasoning.  A hypothetical               
          lender would not lend money to a hypothetical borrower at a rate            
          less than the fair market interest rate.  The usury laws,                   



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011