Chicago Mercantile Exchange - Page 4




                                        - 4 -                                         
                         (B) such lessee is obligated to lease                        
                    the building under an agreement to lease                          
                    entered into before September 26, 1985, and                       
                    such property is provided for such building,                      
                    and                                                               
                         (C) such buildings are to serve as world                     
                    headquarters of the lessee and its                                
                    affiliates.                                                       
               For purposes of this paragraph, a corporation is an                    
               affiliate of another corporation if both corporations                  
               are members of a controlled group of corporations                      
               within the meaning of section 1563(a) of the Internal                  
               Revenue Code of 1954 without regard to section                         
               1563(b)(2) of such Code.  Such lessee shall include a                  
               securities firm that meets the requirements of                         
               subparagraph (A), except the lessee is obligated to                    
               lease the building under a lease entered into on June                  
               18, 1986.                                                              
          We do not conclude that the flush language of this section                  
          exclusively defines the word “affiliates” for purposes of its               
          application.  The flush language merely specifies when a                    
          corporation will be considered to be an affiliate of another                
          corporation.                                                                
               We hold that the flush language of section 204(a)(7)(c) does           
          not contain the exclusive definition of the word “affiliates”.              
          Accordingly, we will deny respondent’s motion and set this case             
          for trial.  Whether petitioner has “affiliates” within the                  
          meaning of section 204(a)(7) is a factual determination that must           
          be made on the basis of a complete record.  We have considered              
          all arguments for a contrary holding and, to the extent not                 
          discussed above, find those arguments to be without merit or                
          irrelevant.  To reflect the foregoing,                                      





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011