Thomas Corson and Judith Corson - Page 15




                                       - 15 -                                         
          section only over denials of relief, or disputes between the                
          Commissioner and the electing spouse regarding such relief (i.e.,           
          partial denials).  Hence, their position is that, since the                 
          nonelecting spouse has no right to raise the issue in this Court            
          if relief is granted prior to a petition by the electing spouse,            
          an anomalous result is created if the nonelecting spouse is                 
          permitted to pursue litigation simply because the issue was                 
          settled after suit was filed but before trial.                              
               With respect to section 6015(g)(2), both respondent and                
          Judith aver that any right to participate afforded to Thomas                
          thereby was not violated.  In addition, respondent maintains that           
          the section has no applicability to the matter at hand because              
          the decision to grant relief was made not in an administrative              
          proceeding but in settlement of a pending court proceeding.                 
               We conclude, for the reasons explained below, that concerns            
          raised by promulgation of the Restructuring Act counsel us to               
          deny respondent’s motion for entry of decision.                             
          III.  Interpretation and Application                                        
               As indicated above, the ultimate issue in this case is                 
          whether Thomas’ objection is a sufficient basis for denial of               
          respondent’s motion.  In addressing this question, we must                  
          determine what bearing, if any, the Restructuring Act has on the            
          right of a nonelecting spouse to litigate a grant of section 6015           
          relief to the electing spouse.                                              






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011