Estate of Morton B. Harper - Page 7




                                        - 7 -                                         
               In our recent opinion in Kerr v. Commissioner, 113 T.C. 449            
          (1999), we held that provisions in a partnership agreement                  
          substantially similar to those in issue in the instant case were            
          not more restrictive than the requirements of the applicable                
          limited partnership law of the State of Texas.  Respondent does             
          not dispute that the provisions of the limited partnership                  
          agreement in the instant case are substantially similar to those            
          at issue in Kerr.  Moreover, respondent does not dispute that               
          there is no substantial difference between California and Texas             
          law with respect to the liquidation of a limited partnership.               
          Unable to distinguish the facts or the law at issue in Kerr,                
          respondent urges this Court to reconsider our opinion in that               
          case.  Because the facts of the instant case are                            
          indistinguishable from those in issue in Kerr, we need not                  
          reiterate our analysis undertaken in Kerr, which we adopt in this           
          opinion.                                                                    
               Accordingly, we hold that the limitations on liquidation               
          contained in the partnership agreement are not applicable                   
          restrictions within the meaning of section 2704(b) and,                     
          consequently, must be taken into account in valuing the limited             
          partnership interests in issue in the instant case.  Therefore we           
          shall deny respondent's motion for partial summary judgment.                










Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011