Helen S. Healer - Page 10




                                       - 10 -                                         
               Petitioner advances an alternative argument as to why the 3-           
          year look-back period in section 6511(b)(2)(A) applies in the               
          instant case.  Petitioner argues that, for purposes of section              
          6511(a), respondent’s substitute for return for petitioner’s tax            
          year 1996 constitutes a return filed by the taxpayer, here                  
          petitioner, on or before April 28, 1999, the date on which                  
          respondent issued the notice to her.  Consequently, according to            
          petitioner, the 3-year look-back period in section 6511(b)(2)(A)            
          applies in the instant case.  Respondent counters that a substi-            
          tute for return prepared by respondent pursuant to section                  
          6020(b)(1) does not constitute a return filed by the taxpayer for           
          purposes of section 6511(a) and that therefore petitioner’s                 
          alternative argument should be rejected.  We agree with respon-             
          dent.                                                                       
               In support of her position that respondent’s substitute for            
          return for petitioner’s tax year 1996 constitutes a return filed            
          by the taxpayer for purposes of section 6511(a), petitioner                 
          relies on section 6020(b)(2).  Section 6020(b) provides in                  
          pertinent part:                                                             
               SEC. 6020.  RETURNS PREPARED FOR OR EXECUTED BY                        
                         SECRETARY.                                                   
                    (b) Execution of Return by Secretary.--                           
                         (1) Authority of secretary to execute                        
                    return.–-If any person fails to make any return                   
                    required by any internal revenue law or regulation                
                    made thereunder at the time prescribed therefor                   
                    * * *, the Secretary shall make such return from                  





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011