Ernest A. and Berniece C. Hunter - Page 2




                                        - 2 -                                         
          Petitioners resided in New York, New York, at the time the                  
          petition was filed.                                                         
               The facts may be summarized as follows.   During 1997, the             
          year before the Court, petitioner was not an employee and was not           
          engaged in any trade or business.  Petitioner testified that his            
          wife “contributes” $100 every 2 weeks for his “library                      
          attendance”.  Petitioners deducted $3,700 on their 1997 tax                 
          return,1 which represents the cost of petitioner’s transportation           
          to and from the libraries and his meals.  As far as we can                  
          determine, since at least 1980 to 1997, petitioner has had an               
          ongoing employment or wrongful discharge dispute with the State             
          of New York.  The following excerpt from the transcript explains            
          petitioner’s position:                                                      
                    THE COURT:  But you are not engaged in a trade or                 
               business, are you?                                                     
                    THE WITNESS:  * * * I am not.  But what happens is in             
               the civil service law, in order to get paid, you have to               
               maintain a posture of ready, willing and able to be restored           
               from the preferred list, or whatever.  And what happens is             
               that has been my method or means of keeping myself ready,              
               willing and able to be employed.                                       
                         *    *    *    *    *    *    *                              
               I am not receiving a penny [of income].  See, what happens             
               is, when the State of New York refused to restore me from              
               the preferred list, they refused to provide me with any                
               interpretation of whatever it was that they -– reasons they            

               1   The record does not explain the difference between $100            
          every 2 weeks ($2,400) and the $3,700 deduction petitioners                 
          claimed on their return.                                                    






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011