Malvern Hills Trust - Page 6




                                        - 6 -                                         

          petition as petitioner’s so-called contractor.  The trust                   
          instrument does not define the term “contractor”, and it does not           
          set forth the powers, duties, or responsibilities of a person who           
          holds that title.7  Nor is petitioner’s trustee a party to this             
          proceeding.  According to the trust instrument, petitioner’s                
          trustee is Zola Sheenan, and the petition that was filed with the           
          Court by Mr. Jablonski makes no reference to Ms. Sheenan.                   
               Petitioner has left us unpersuaded that we have jurisdiction           
          over its case.  Thus, we shall grant respondent’s motion to                 
          dismiss this case for lack of jurisdiction.8  See AL Trust v.               
          Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2000-276; YMO Trust v. Commissioner,               
          T.C. Memo. 2000-275; BHC Trust v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2000-            



          6(...continued)                                                             
          Mr. Jablonski to respondent’s counsel, that Mr. Jabonski signed             
          as “Trustee” (sic).  However, the trust instrument does not name            
          Mr. Jablonski as trustee.  The record as a whole does not support           
          a finding that Mr. Jablonski is petitioner’s trustee.                       
          7 By contrast, the trust instrument provides explicitly that                
          “THE TRUSTEES shall hold all property of the Trust Organization             
          as joint tenants in fee simple and shall comprise the Board of              
          Trustees for conducting the affairs of the Trust Organization.”             
          The trust instrument provides further that “THE TRUSTEES shall              
          hold office and exercise collectively the control of the Trust              
          Organization property and affairs.  All major actions and                   
          decisions * * * on the part of the Trust Organization shall be              
          made by the Trustees acting unanimously”.                                   
          8 Petitioner has also failed to persuade us that it actually                
          existed on the date of the petition.  We lack jurisdiction when a           
          petitioning trust is a nonexisting entity.  See Patz v.                     
          Commissioner, 69 T.C. 497, 501 (1977).                                      





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011