James Mess and Janet Mess - Page 3




                                                - 3 -                                                  
            $5,676 on their 1996 joint Federal income tax return.  Upon                                
            examination, respondent determined that the $5,676 was taxable                             
            income.                                                                                    
                                             Discussion                                                
                  Section 61(a) defines gross income to include “all income                            
            from whatever source derived, including (but not limited to) the                           
            following items: * * * (11) Pensions”.  Military retirement pay                            
            is a pension.  See Eatinger v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 1990-310.                          
            The pension payments that petitioner received were made pursuant                           
            to her community property interest in the military retirement                              
            pension of her former husband.  Petitioner, however, argues that,                          
            if as originally set forth in the final judgment, her former                               
            husband had received retirement payments and she had received the                          
            payments from him, the amounts would not be taxable to her.  But                           
            that is exactly the situation in Eatinger v. Commissioner, supra,                          
            where this Court held, on facts substantially identical to those                           
            here, that under California law a former spouse had a property                             
            interest in the former husband’s military pension and, therefore,                          
            under section 61 the receipt of the military pension was taxable                           
            to her even though it was received through the former husband.                             
            The question is, under the applicable California law, to whom the                          
            income belongs.  The answer here, as in Eatinger, is that it                               
            belonged to the former wife, petitioner.  See also Graham v.                               








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011