Estate of Paul C. Gribauskas - Page 9




                                        - 9 -                                         
          after December 13, 1995.  See sec. 20.7520-3(c), Estate Tax Regs.           
          These exceptions, where pertinent, will be discussed in greater             
          detail below.                                                               
          II.  Contentions of the Parties                                             
               The fundamental disagreement between the parties concerns              
          whether the stream of lottery payments constitutes an annuity               
          which must be valued pursuant to the actuarial tables prescribed            
          under section 7520.                                                         
               The estate concedes that the prize’s value is properly                 
          included in calculating decedent’s gross estate under the general           
          rule of section 2033, as “an unsecured debt obligation” in which            
          decedent had an interest at death.  However, the estate denies              
          that the payments are similarly includible as an annuity under              
          section 2039.  According to the estate, the lottery prize fails             
          to meet the specific requirements set forth in section 2039(a)              
          for classification as an annuity under that section.  Moreover,             
          even if such criteria were deemed satisfied, the estate maintains           
          that operation of section 2039(b) would result in including only            
          that portion of the asset equal to the $1.00 purchase price, a de           
          minimis amount.                                                             
               From these propositions, and to a significant degree                   
          apparently equating the term “annuity” in section 2039 with use             
          of the word in section 7520, the estate argues that the LOTTO               
          payments need not be valued under the prescribed actuarial                  






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011