Eugene M. Landry - Page 6




                                        - 6 -                                         
          was about to pass.  When that time came, however, family and                
          employment obligations allegedly interfered with his plan.  In              
          other words, he knowingly failed to comply with his annual                  
          obligation to file a tax return, and he now seeks relief because            
          he has lost refunds or credits to which he otherwise was                    
          entitled.                                                                   
               We are not impressed with petitioner’s “equitable” argument.           
          Even if we were, however, we are bound by the strict terms of the           
          statutory provisions limiting refunds or credits for overpayments           
          to those properly claimed within 3 years of the date paid.  See             
          sec. 6511(b); United States v. Brockamp, 519 U.S. 347, 352-354              
          (1997).  Payments made by withholding from petitioner’s wages are           
          deemed paid on the 15th day of the 4th month following the close            
          of the tax year.  See sec. 6513(b)(1).  To the extent that                  
          overpayments were designated as estimated tax payments for a                
          subsequent year, they were deemed made on the last day for filing           
          the return.  See sec. 6513(b)(2).  Application of the credits in            
          dispute was clearly barred.                                                 
               As a matter of law, petitioner is not entitled to credit for           
          an amount paid or deemed paid more than 3 years before a return             
          claiming a credit of that amount was filed.  Respondent correctly           
          determined that collection efforts should proceed.                          










Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011