David J. Lychuk and Mary K. Lychuk, et al. - Page 78




                                       - 75 -                                         
          all of the installment loans investigated and considered of 6.6             
          months for 1993 and 7.4 months for 1994.1  Because a majority of            
          the installment loans investigated and considered by ACC were               
          never purchased and because the average life of all of the                  
          installment loans (factoring in all installment loans                       
          investigated and considered) was not beyond one year, I believe             
          it would be erroneous to conclude generally that the allegedly              
          related salaries and overhead provided benefits to ACC with a               
          life “substantially beyond” one year.                                       
               (3) The salaries and overhead were not paid by ACC in                  
          connection with any specific installment loans.  Note the Supreme           
          Court’s words, also from Commissioner v. Idaho Power Co., 418               
          U.S. at 13, linking expenditures to be capitalized to specific              
          capital assets:                                                             


                    But when wages [salaries] are paid in connection with             
                    the construction or acquisition of a capital asset,               
                    they must be capitalized and are then entitled to be              



               1   My computation of the average life of ACC’s installment            
          loans investigated and considered (including in the “Total” loans           
          those installment loans rejected or withdrawn) is shown below:              
               Number of Installment Loans                                            
               Rejected or                   Average Duration    Average Duration     
     Year      Withdrawn  Accepted Total     of Accepted Loans   of All Loans*        
     1993      1,131     693       1,824     17.5 months         6.6 months           
     1994      1,338     820       2,158     19.5 months         7.4 months           
               * For 1993 [(1,131 V 0) + (693 V 17.5)]  1,824 = 6.6.                 
               For 1994 [(1,338 V 0) + (820 V 19.5)]  2,158 = 7.4.                   





Page:  Previous  65  66  67  68  69  70  71  72  73  74  75  76  77  78  79  80  81  82  83  84  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011