Paul A. Tanner, Sr. and Beverly N. Tanner - Page 14




                                       - 14 -                                         
          year.8  Id. at 30376.  We, therefore, find petitioner’s argument            
          to be without merit.                                                        
               We conclude that the 6-month period of section 16(b) began             
          at the “purchase” date--the date of the grant of the option.  If            
          we consider solely the liability created by section 16(b), the              
          section 16(b) period expired before the option was exercised, and           
          section 83(c)(3) is not applicable.                                         
               5.   Does the Lockup Agreement Extend the 6-month Period of            
                    Section 16(b) to 2 Years?                                         
               Petitioner further argues that the lockup agreement provided           
          by contract that petitioner would be subject to section 16(b) for           
          2 years instead of only the statutory period of 6 months.                   
          Respondent argues that there is no provision in section 16(b)               
          that allows individuals to voluntarily subject themselves to                
          liability under the statute.                                                
               Section 83(c)(3) applies only “So long as the sale of the              
          property at a profit could subject a person to suit under section           
          16(b)”.  Section 1.83-3(j)(1), Income Tax Regs., provides:                  
               For purposes of section 83 and the regulations                         
               thereunder if the sale of property at a profit within                  
               six months after the purchase of the property could                    
               subject a person to suit under section 16(b) of the                    
               Securities Exchange Act of 1934, the person’s rights in                


               8  We note that discretionary transactions are not excluded            
          in the 1991 version of this regulation.  See Final rules and                
          solicitation of comments:  Ownership Reports and Trading by                 
          Officers, Directors and Principal Security Holders, 56 Fed. Reg.            
          at 7270.                                                                    






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011