Estate of H.A. True, Jr. - Page 76




                                       - 16 -                                         
          corporation to build and operate a gathering system for the                 
          Donkey Creek field in the Powder River Basin.  Dave True and the            
          other local operators organized Bell Fourche because they had               
          encountered difficulty in getting their crude oil to market from            
          newly discovered, remote fields.  They therefore decided to build           
          their own pipeline, rather than transport crude oil by truck to             
          trunk lines or connect new wells to existing gathering pipelines            
          owned by others.  In later years, Belle Fourche substantially               
          expanded its operations to serve other fields as a common carrier           
          gathering system with multiple outlets to trunk lines.                      
              Belle Fourche generated substantial cash-flow from fees for             
          transporting crude oil.  Its customers included both True                   
          companies and unrelated entities.  However, the majority of its             
          business was from unrelated entities.                                       
              In the 1960's, Dave and Jean True acquired full ownership of            
          the shares of Belle Fourche through redemptions of the share                
          interests of the other holders.7  There were no buy-sell                    
          agreements that would have dictated the redemption prices for               
          Belle Fourche stock.  All but one of the redemptions were at                
          preceding yearend book value (determined on a GAAP basis, see               




               7Petitioners’ direct testimony characterized these                     
          transactions as stock purchases by Dave and Jean True, while the            
          appraisal of Standard Research Consultants (SRC)(see infra pp.              
          37-39) characterized them as corporate redemptions.  The SRC                
          appraisal provided more detailed information regarding the                  
          transactions and appears to be more reliable.                               




Page:  Previous  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011