Charles C. Allen, III and Barbara N. Allen, et al. - Page 25




                                        - 25 -                                          
          position by stating “For most purposes, the tax base * * * is                 
          determined as though the alternative minimum tax were a separate              
          and independent income tax system.”  General Explanation of the               
          1986 Act, supra at 438 (emphasis added).  To our minds, the                   
          phrase “For most purposes” means that even the Joint Committee                
          recognized that the regular tax and AMT systems were not parallel             
          systems for all purposes.  The same is true as to the use of the              
          term “as though”, rather than a term such as “by virtue of the                
          fact that”.  As to the Joint Committee’s use of the term                      
          “separate and independent”, we find no statement in the General               
          Explanation of the 1986 Act to the effect that the two regimes                
          are separate and independent for all purposes.  And even if we                
          did, the mere fact that two systems are “separate and                         
          independent” does not make them “parallel”.                                   
               The General Explanation of the 1986 Act uses the word                    
          “parallel” only twice in its discussion of AMT.  First, as to the             
          treatment of AMT NOLs, the General Explanation of the 1986 Act                
          states:                                                                       
                    In light of the parallel nature of the regular tax                  
               and minimum tax systems, any limitations applying for                    
               regular tax purposes to the use by a consolidated group                  
               of NOLs or current year losses (e.g., section 1503)                      
               apply for minimum tax purposes as well.  Moreover, an                    
               election under section 172(b)(3)(C) to relinquish the                    
               carryback period applies for both regular tax and                        
               minimum purposes.  [General Explanation of the 1986                      
               Act, supra at 470.]                                                      








Page:  Previous  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011