Estate of Elma Middleton Dailey, Deceased, Donor, K. Robert Dailey, II, Executor - Page 7




                                        - 7 -                                         
          hours3) is the appropriate amount allocated to the FLP issue.               
          The following chart represents the petitioners’ proposed                    
          allocation of hours:                                                        
                                                  FLP       Valuation                 
                                                  (hours)    (hours)                  
          Jeffrey A. Schumacher (expert)          0         77.95                     
                                                  00                                  
                    Subtotal-Jeffrey A. Schumacher               77.95                
          Harold A. Chamberlain (lead attorney)                                       
               Pleadings                          30        0                         
               Summary judgment                   7         0                         
               Expert witness                     0         31                        
               Conference with district counsel   21        1                         
               Pre-trial prep/memorandum/motions  77        15                        
               Trial-day 1                        10        0                         
               Trial-day 2                        10        2                         
               Briefing and posttrial review      106       0                         
               Review respondent’s posttrial brief3         0                         
               Motion                             40        0                         
                                                  40304                               
                    Subtotal-Harold A. Chamberlain               49                   
          Michael C. Riddle, Esq. (attorney)                                          
               Conferences with Chamberlain       37        0                         
               Trial-Day 1                        10        0                         
               Trial-Day 2                        10        2                         
                                                  1057                                
                    Subtotal-Michael C. Riddle                   2                    
                    Total (489.95 hours)               361       128.95               
               Petitioners allocated 106 hours to the FLP issue relating to           
          briefing and posttrial review by Chamberlain.  This allocation is           
          unreasonable because the parties’ findings of fact predominantly            
          deal with valuation and more than 80 percent of their brief is              
          dedicated to valuation.  Moreover, the portion of the brief                 
          dedicated to the FLP issue merely references Knight v.                      
          Commissioner, 115 T.C. 506 (2000), and Estate of Strangi v.                 
          Commissioner, 115 T.C. 478 (2000), revd. on other grounds 293               
          F.3d 279 (5th Cir. 2002), which are decisions in which the Court            
          held that an FLP is not disregarded for tax purposes.  Under                


               3  Respondent, however, neglected to exclude 47 hours of               
          time that petitioners allocated to the valuation issue.                     



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011