Ruth Ferrarese - Page 7




                                        - 7 -                                         
               No single factor will be determinative of whether                      
               equitable relief will or will not be granted in any                    
               particular case.  Rather, all factors will be                          
               considered and weighed appropriately.  The list is not                 
               intended to be exhaustive.                                             
               In deciding whether respondent’s determination that                    
          petitioner is not entitled to relief under section 6015(f) was an           
          abuse of discretion, we will consider evidence relating to all              
          the facts and circumstances.                                                
          C.   Whether Petitioner Is Entitled to Equitable Relief                     
               Respondent concedes that the deficiency is attributable to             
          Ferrarese.  Petitioner concedes that the marital status and                 
          spousal abuse factors do not favor her, and that the knowledge or           
          reason to know factor favors respondent.  The parties agree that            
          the legal obligation factor does not apply because petitioner and           
          Ferrarese are not divorced.  As discussed next, we conclude that            
          the disputed factors all favor petitioner.                                  
               1.   Economic Hardship                                                 
               Respondent contends that petitioner offered no evidence that           
          she would suffer economic hardship if relief is denied.  We                 
          disagree.  Petitioner testified that her only source of income              
          was Social Security, that she could barely pay her bills, that              
          she and Ferrarese must borrow from their children to pay                    
          expenses, and that she would have to sell her condominium if she            
          were denied relief under section 6015(f).  Respondent did not               








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011