Gerald R. Grace - Page 4




                                        - 3 -                                         
          total Social Security benefits to $7,251.60, thereby increasing             
          the amount included in petitioner’s gross income to $6,163.                 
               Gross income includes “all income from whatever source                 
          derived”, unless specifically excluded.  Sec. 61(a).  Generally,            
          gross income does not include “amounts received under workmen’s             
          compensation acts as compensation for personal injuries or                  
          sickness.”  Sec. 104(a)(1).  Social Security benefits, however,             
          are included in gross income as provided by section 86.  If the             
          amount of Social Security benefits a taxpayer receives is reduced           
          because of the receipt of workers’ compensation benefits, the               
          amount of the workers’ compensation benefits which caused the               
          reduction (“the offset amount”) is included in gross income in              
          the same manner as a Social Security benefit.  Sec. 86(d)(3);               
          Mikalonis v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2000-281.                             
               Petitioner argues that section 104(a)(1) should in effect              
          “trump” section 86.  However, the statutes must be read together:           
          Section 104(a)(1) provides the general rule that workers’                   
          compensation benefits are not gross income.  Section 86(d)(3)               
          provides the exception to this general rule that the offset                 
          amount is included in income in the same manner as a Social                 
          Security benefit.  This has the effect of equalizing the Federal            
          tax treatment of Social Security benefits available to various              
          taxpayers who may or may not be eligible to receive workers’                
          compensation benefits.  See H. Rept. 98-25, at 26 (1983).                   






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011