Hilton H. Hackley - Page 9




                                        - 9 -                                         
          years in issue Ms. Orum, and not petitioner, was (1) the legal              
          owner of the LA property and (2) indebted to Countrywide on the             
          mortgage loan it had made on the property.  Although we find that           
          petitioner may have made mortgage payments, real estate tax                 
          payments, and insurance premium payments for the LA residence,              
          there is no objective evidence to persuade us that he had                   
          equitable ownership of the LA residence during the years in                 
          issue.  The record lacks sufficient evidence, most notably Ms.              
          Orum’s testimony, of the purported arrangement with petitioner.             
          Further, petitioner testified that Ms. Orum made no deposits into           
          their joint checking account, where all mortgage, insurance, and            
          real estate tax payments were made.  His testimony, without more,           
          is insufficient.  See Loria v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 1995-420            
          (taxpayer’s attempt to establish equitable ownership with his               
          sole testimony is insufficient).                                            
               Based upon our examination of the entire record in this                
          case, we find that petitioner failed to establish that he was the           
          equitable owner of the LA property during the years in issue, or            
          that he is entitled to deduct for those years the mortgage loan             
          interest he paid on that property.  We therefore sustain                    
          respondent’s determination disallowing the mortgage loan interest           
          deductions that petitioner claimed on his 1995 and 1996 returns.            
               Petitioner claimed Schedule A deductions for real estate               
          taxes paid of $2,087 and $2,309 on his respective 1995 and 1996             






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011