Estate of Morton B. Harper, Deceased, Michael A. Harper, Executor - Page 70




                                       - 70 -                                         
          Reserve Statistical Release, to the 10-percent rate born by the             
          Marsh note.  He concluded that the spread of 87 basis points was            
          reasonable.  Mr. Cronkite indicated that he did not research                
          interest rates, the estate has offered no alternative evidence or           
          position, and we have no grounds for doubt of Mr. Thomson’s                 
          assumptions on this matter.                                                 
               Turning to the two factors that Mr. Thomson felt would                 
          increase any applicable discount, we begin with that pertaining             
          to maturity date and extensions.  Mr. Thomson indicated that,               
          given the repeated annual extensions of maturity, there existed a           
          lack of assurance that the note would be paid in full at its                
          upcoming due date.  He viewed this circumstance as one which                
          would favor an increase in discount.  Again, the estate has not             
          challenged the foregoing premise, and we note Mr. Cronkite                  
          testified with similar import.  Mr. Cronkite stated:  “whether              
          there’s a pending maturity date, I think is kind of moot.  I                
          believe everyone thought it wouldn’t--it wouldn’t be paid at the            
          maturity date.”   We find Mr. Thomson’s analysis of maturity                
          issues to be logical.                                                       
               The remaining factor identified by Mr. Thomson as tending to           
          support an increased discount focuses on environmental concerns.            
          Both parties and their experts are in agreement insofar as the              
          notion that environmental issues relating to the mobile home park           
          detract from the value of the Marsh note.  The estate, however,             






Page:  Previous  56  57  58  59  60  61  62  63  64  65  66  67  68  69  70  71  72  73  74  75  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011