State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company and Subsidiaries - Page 22




                                       - 22 -                                         
          must be rejected.  As petitioner emphasizes, appropriate                    
          allocation of the adjustment, where necessary, can accommodate              
          these limitations in arriving at ATNOL or AMTI within the context           
          of the otherwise mandated consolidated approach.                            
               (Although it is unnecessary here to reach the mechanics of             
          an appropriate allocation, we note that the idea of allocation of           
          consolidated adjustments is not foreign to the consolidated                 
          return regime.  As regards the book income adjustment in                    
          particular, commentators have observed that allocation of the               
          consolidated adjustment could be required in situations involving           
          groups other than life-nonlife entities, such as where a member             
          joins or departs from a consolidated group, and have suggested              
          possible allocation methods.  See Sair & Axelrod, “Issues and               
          Uncertainties in Consolidated AMT”, 305 PLI/Tax 141, 166-168                
          (1990) (advancing two potential allocation strategies:                      
          Allocation based on each corporation’s relative book income as              
          compared to the total net book income and pro rata allocation               
          based on book income adjustment amounts).  With respect to                  
          consolidated adjustments besides that for book income, certain              
          regulations provide for allocation or attribution to particular             
          group members.  For instance, petitioner cites sections 1.1502-             
          21(b) and 1.1502-55(h)(4)(iii)(B)(1), Income Tax Regs.,                     
          promulgated after the years relevant here, as prescribing rules             
          for determining, respectively, the portion of a consolidated NOL            






Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011