Acme Equipment Trust, Robert Hogue, Trustee - Page 11




                                       - 10 -                                         
          and a Michael Welch and a Carol Ruthenberg as trustees.  The                
          second document, dated January 13, 1997, identifies a Carol                 
          Ruthenberg as “creator” and Robert Hogue as trustee.                        
          Significantly, Acme made no attempt to explain the patent                   
          discrepancies in the two purported trust documents-–particularly            
          the change in identity of the trust “creator” and the change in             
          identity of the trustees.  We note further that although the 1994           
          version of the trust instrument required a minimum of two                   
          trustees, the 1997 version required only one trustee.                       
               As if the foregoing were not sufficiently confusing, yet               
          another purported settlor of Acme, a Robin Morgan, is identified            
          in “First Minutes” received by respondent from Robert Hogue.                
          Other “Minutes”, described supra G. of the Background section of            
          this opinion, muddle the matter further.                                    
               In the absence of any persuasive basis for concluding that             
          Robert Hogue was duly appointed as the trustee of Acme, we shall            
          dismiss this case for lack of jurisdiction consistent with                  
          respondent’s motion, as supplemented.  See Bella Vista                      
          Chiropractic Trust v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2003-8.                      
               All of the arguments and contentions that have not been                
          analyzed herein have been considered, but they do not require any           
          further discussion.                                                         










Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011