Charles Johns - Page 3

                                        - 3 -                                         
          petitioner assigned his right to receive one annual lottery                 
          payment of $470,000, scheduled to be made on December 8, 2001, to           
          Singer in exchange for $386,500.  Petitioner received $1.5                  
          million in payments from Singer in 1998 pursuant to those                   
          agreements.  Petitioner reported the $1.5 million in payments               
          from Singer as long-term capital gain on Schedule D, Capital                
          Gains and Losses, of his 1998 Federal income tax return.                    
          Respondent determined that those payments are ordinary income to            
          petitioner.                                                                 
               Petitioner agrees that the facts of our recent opinion in              
          Davis v. Commissioner, 119 T.C. 1 (2002), are “nearly identical”            
          to the facts in the instant case.  In Davis, we held that the               
          taxpayers’ right to receive certain future annual lottery                   
          payments did not constitute a capital asset within the meaning of           
          section 1221 and that the lump-sum amount that the taxpayers                
          received for their right to receive the future annual lottery               
          payments was ordinary income and not capital gain.  Id. at 7.               
               Petitioner asks us to revisit our opinion in Davis, because            
          the taxpayer in that case did not argue, and we did not consider,           
          whether the winning lottery ticket was a capital asset, and                 
          because of our interpretation of the U.S. Supreme Court opinion             
          in Ark. Best Corp. v. Commissioner, 485 U.S. 212 (1988).                    
          Petitioner contends that the winning lottery ticket is “property”           








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011