Louis E. Peyton - Page 7

                                        - 7 -                                         
                    It has been over twelve years since this alleged                  
               underpayment occurred.  The Petitioner has no                          
               documentation at all with regard to these years.  As                   
               far as witnesses are concerned, I have had no contact                  
               with any of the individuals who could have testified at                
               trial. * * *                                                           
          Consistent with the above representation, none of the five items            
          attached to the motion to reopen the record constituted                     
          documentation or records germane to any transaction purportedly             
          underlying respondent’s determinations.  Four of the documents              
          consisted of copies of correspondence sent by petitioner to                 
          respondent and related primarily to negotiation of a stipulation            
          that was never received by the Court and to an unsuccessful                 
          attempt to compromise the case.  The remaining item merely                  
          summarized petitioner’s contentions in the face of various of               
          respondent’s allegations.                                                   
               Respondent objected to the motion to reopen the record,                
          citing rule 408 of the Federal Rules of Evidence and additionally           
          protesting that petitioner’s documents contained arguments rather           
          than evidence.  Petitioner’s motion to reopen the record was                
          denied, the order to show cause was made absolute, and respondent           
          was directed to file with the Court proposed findings of fact and           
          a memorandum of law.  Respondent filed the requested materials,             
          setting forth in detail respondent’s position and also making               
          certain concessions.  In particular, respondent asserted that               
          petitioner received unreported income from marijuana sales of               
          $160,000 for each year in issue, rather than $170,000 as asserted           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011