Ray W. and Marilyn S. Sowards - Page 14

                                       - 14 -                                         
               Credible evidence is the quality of evidence which,                    
               after critical analysis, the court would find                          
               sufficient upon which to base a decision on the issue                  
               if no contrary evidence were submitted (without regard                 
               to the judicial presumption of IRS correctness).  A                    
               taxpayer has not produced credible evidence for these                  
               purposes if the taxpayer merely makes implausible                      
               factual assertions, frivolous claims, or tax protestor-                
               type arguments.  The introduction of evidence will not                 
               meet this standard if the court is not convinced that                  
               it is worthy of belief.  If after evidence from both                   
               sides, the court believes that the evidence is equally                 
               balanced, the court shall find that the Secretary has                  
               not sustained his burden of proof.  [H. Conf. Rept.                    
               105-599, at 240-241 (1998), 1998-3 C.B. 747, 994-995.]                 
          See Higbee v. Commissioner, 116 T.C. 438 (2001).  In support of             
          his position that amounts received from STL were loans, Mr.                 
          Sowards offered only his self-serving testimony and an alleged              
          loan document.  We find that Mr. Sowards was not a credible                 
          witness; his testimony was vague, inconsistent, and implausible.            
          Further, as detailed infra, we find that the payments from STL              
          were received for services that Mr. Sowards rendered.  Mr.                  
          Sowards also failed to present credible evidence that other                 
          deposits to his bank accounts were not taxable income or that               
          deductions disallowed by respondent should be allowed.  As such,            
          we find that Mr. Sowards failed to present credible evidence.               
          See Higbee v. Commissioner, supra; Tokh v. Commissioner, T.C.               
          Memo. 2001-45, affd. 25 Fed. Appx. 440 (7th Cir. 2001).                     
               In addition, the application of section 7491(a)(1) is                  
          limited by section 7491(a)(2), which provides in pertinent part:            
                    SEC. 7491(a).  Burden Shifts Where Taxpayer                       
               Produces Credible Evidence.--                                          





Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011