William Herbert Whitehurst, III and Carla Cherlene Whitehurst - Page 9




                                        - 8 -                                         
               Mrs. Whitehurst did not maintain or produce to either                  
          respondent’s agent or the Court a journal or a book of accounts             
          for the bowling activity.  Mrs. Whitehurst, however, maintained             
          and produced numerous hotel, restaurant, gasoline, credit card,             
          and rental car receipts, airplane tickets, copies of canceled               
          checks, bank records, and bowling tournament score sheets that              
          reflect the expenses incurred with respect to the bowling                   
          activity.  Mrs. Whitehurst recorded her expenses by “just jotting           
          information down on the tournament flyer” because the tournaments           
          were hectic.  While her records were somewhat disorganized and              
          partially incomplete, they generally reflect her receipts and               
          expenses.  Petitioners did not maintain a separate bank account             
          for the bowling activity.                                                   
               Because Mrs. Whitehurst had not been able to win any of the            
          large tournaments offering large prize winnings (i.e., $20,000 or           
          $40,000), she changed her strategy during 1998 and decided to               
          compete in more local and smaller tournaments.  In 1999, Mrs.               
          Whitehurst changed her strategy again and she decided to compete            
          in more tournaments in Florida that offered the larger prize                
          winnings.  She stopped competing in tournaments in 2000.  Her               
          changes in strategy and ultimate decision to stop competing in              
          tournaments both support her claim that she entered into the                
          activity with a profit objective.  See id.                                  








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011