Robert Harold Hathaway - Page 5

                                        - 5 -                                         
          taxpayer of his right to a hearing before an impartial Appeals              
          officer.  Sec. 6320.  Pursuant to section 6320(c) the hearing               
          is to be conducted pursuant to the rules provided in subsections            
          (c), (d) (other than paragraph (2)(B) thereof), and (e) of                  
          section 6330.  If the Commissioner issues a determination letter            
          adverse to the position of the taxpayer, the taxpayer may seek              
          judicial review of the determination.  Sec. 6330(d).                        
               This Court has established the following standards of review           
          in considering whether a taxpayer is entitled to relief from the            
          Commissioner’s determination:                                               
               where the validity of the underlying tax liability is                  
               properly at issue, the Court will review the matter on                 
               a de novo basis.  However, where the validity of the                   
               underlying tax liability is not properly at issue, the                 
               Court will review the Commissioner’s administrative                    
               determination for abuse of discretion.                                 
          Sego v. Commissioner, 114 T.C. 604, 610 (2000).                             
               Petitioner essentially makes three arguments regarding his             
          unpaid tax liability and respondent’s collection actions (i.e.,             
          the filing of the tax lien).  First, he posits that he                      
          incorrectly reported income for 1996 and 1997 because he had no             
          “statutory income” to report.  Second, petitioner claims that               
          unless and until respondent can produce a “statutory notice and             
          demand” and a signed assessment document, no valid section 6330             
          hearing can be conducted.  And finally, petitioner maintains that           








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011