Narvell Darling - Page 10

                                       - 10 -                                         
          to support his contention that he attempted to file an insurance            
          claim as a result of the flood.                                             
               Petitioner also testified as to his calculation of his                 
          claimed casualty loss deduction.  Petitioner calculated such                
          casualty loss deduction by inventorying the damaged and destroyed           
          carpeting and personal property items as they were “hauled away”.           
          He then found purchase receipts for these items.  Petitioner                
          “depreciated” all items by 10 percent of their purchase price, no           
          matter how long he had owned the item.  Petitioner then                     
          calculated his casualty loss by using the sum of all the                    
          depreciated values and applying the limitations of section                  
          165(h).                                                                     
               Petitioner did not attempt to recreate the above-described             
          inventory list of items that were damaged or destroyed.                     
          Petitioner did not attempt to obtain receipts for repairs to the            
          premises.  Petitioner did not call, as witnesses to substantiate            
          the casualty loss, any of the individuals who allegedly helped              
          him pump the water out of his basement or helped him dispose of             
          the damaged or destroyed items of personal property.                        
               Petitioner has presented no reliable evidence of any repairs           
          made to his townhouse or to the personal property items that were           
          damaged or destroyed as a result of the flood.  The only evidence           
          presented by petitioner to support his claimed losses is his own            
          self-serving testimony.  This Court is not bound to accept a                






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011