Elizabeth Giles - Page 13

                                       - 13 -                                         
          leasing it.  This first breeding produced VT Kartel.  She bred              
          Borissa a second time in 1991.  This breeding, which apparently             
          also was connected with petitioner’s payment of the $5,000                  
          breeding fee,9 produced Bogaz on May 19, 1991.10  She bred Borissa          
          a third time between July 7 and September 30, 1997, in the sense            
          that she paid a $3,000 breeding fee to the Bishop Lane Farm to              
          board, care for, and breed (including possibly by artificial                
          insemination) Borissa with a named stallion.11  This breeding               
          produced the referenced horse that was stillborn in 1998.  She              
          then bred Borissa a fourth and final time in 2000.  This final              
          breeding produced Censuous in 2001.                                         
               Petitioner continues to own Borissa, and she keeps it at the           
          Falling Water Way property.  As of the time of petitioner’s                 
          trial, Borissa’s fair market value was not more than $20,000.               
          Borissa is the only horse that petitioner has bred since 1989,              


               9 Although the contract underlying the $5,000 breeding fee             
          refers only to GoKart, and the stallion that helped produce Bogaz           
          was not GoKart, petitioner deducted no other breeding fees from             
          1988 until 1997.                                                            
               10 Although the record does not indicate the period of                 
          gestation for a horse such as Borissa, we recognize that the                
          length of this pregnancy was 20 weeks at the most.  Given that              
          the parties have stipulated that Bogaz was the product of a 1991            
          breeding of Borissa and that the record establishes that Bogaz              
          was foaled on May 19, 1991, we find the relevant dates of this              
          pregnancy accordingly.                                                      
               11 Petitioner also paid as to this breeding a $250 fee for             
          the transportation of semen.  She deducted the total breeding fee           
          of $3,250 ($3,000 + $250) for 1997.                                         





Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011