Billy Hyler and Bonita M. Hyler - Page 3

                                        - 3 -                                         
          behalf as $92,636.  Petitioners entered $92,636 on Form 1040,               
          line 64 (“Other payments”) and claimed a refund on a total                  
          overpayment of $92,861.                                                     
               Petitioners each signed the tax return.  The tax return was            
          not signed by a tax return preparer.  Respondent processed the              
          tax return and issued to petitioners a refund check in the amount           
          of $93,071.                                                                 
               On March 24, 2004, respondent issued a notice of deficiency            
          to petitioners for the taxable year 2000.  In the notice,                   
          respondent determined a deficiency in petitioners’ income tax in            
          the amount of $92,636, asserting:                                           
               The claim you filed on Form 2439 includes a credit that                
               you assert is owed to you as a reparation or tax rebate                
               based on the impact of slavery.  Since there is no law                 
               allowing this type of payment, we cannot honor this                    
               type of credit.  Accordingly, your income tax liability                
               has been increased based on the credit recapture.  Due                 
               to the allowance of the credit, you will need to return                
               the portion of your refund based on the disallowed                     
               amount.                                                                
               Petitioners filed a timely petition challenging the notice             
          of deficiency.3  In the petition, petitioners contend that                  
          respondent should attempt to collect the amount in dispute from             
          their tax return preparer “if he was behaving fraudulently” in              
          this matter.  Petitioners also allege that the period of                    




               3  At the time the petition was filed, petitioners resided             
          in Columbia, Missouri.                                                      





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011