Maguire/Thomas Partners Fifth & Grand, Ltd., Maguire/Thomas Partners Grand Place Tower, Ltd., Tax Matters Partner - Page 32

                                        - 32 -                                        
          incurred to obtain the zoning change,11 and (2) the remaining               
          $6,674,552 was incurred to obtain the Grand Tower variation.12              
               We hold that Library Square may depreciate and include in              
          the depreciable basis of Library Tower the $7,143,156 that we               
          have determined is attributable to obtaining the Library Tower              
          variation.  We further hold that Library Tower may not                      
          depreciate the $11,799,493 that we have determined is                       
          attributable to obtaining the zoning change, as that zoning                 
          change produced benefits of an indefinite and undeterminable                
          duration with respect to the Library Tower parcel land.  Galt v.            
          Commissioner, 19 T.C. at 910.                                               
               We hold that Fifth & Grand may depreciate and include in               
          the depreciable basis of Grand Place Tower the $6,674,552 that              
          we have determined is attributable to obtaining the Grand Place             
          Tower variation.  We further hold that Fifth & Grand may not                
          depreciate the $11,025,448 that we have determined is                       
          attributable to obtaining the zoning change because the zoning              
          change produced benefits of an indefinite and undeterminable                







               11  $17,700,000 x   747,488 sq. ft.  = $11,025,448.                    
          1,200,000 sq. ft.                                                           
               12  $17,700,000 x   452,512 sq. ft.  = $6,674,552.                     
          1,200,000 sq. ft.                                                           




Page:  Previous  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011