Eleanor Simon - Page 17

                                       - 17 -                                         
                         (2) relief is not available to such individ-                 
                    ual under subsection (b) or (c),                                  
               the Secretary may relieve such individual of such                      
               liability.                                                             
          In the instant case, the parties agree that relief is not avail-            
          able to petitioner under section 6015(b) or (c), thereby satisfy-           
          ing section 6015(f)(2).  They disagree over whether petitioner is           
          entitled to relief under section 6015(f).                                   
               In support of her position that she is entitled to relief              
          under section 6015(f), petitioner relies, inter alia, on the                
          testimony of Mr. Simon and her own testimony.  We found Mr.                 
          Simon’s testimony to be questionable and not credible in certain            
          material respects.  For example, Mr. Simon testified that he                
          signed petitioner’s name on the 1998 return.  We did not believe            
          that testimony.  We also found Mr. Simon’s testimony to be at               
          times confusing, confused, internally inconsistent, and/or                  
          inconsistent with certain of the parties’ stipulations of fact              
          and certain exhibits attached to those stipulations (stipulated             
          exhibits).  We shall not rely on Mr. Simon’s testimony to support           
          petitioner’s position in this case.  We also found petitioner’s             
          testimony to be questionable and not credible in certain material           
          respects.  For example, petitioner testified that she did not               
          sign the 1998 return.  We did not believe that testimony.                   
          Moreover, petitioner’s testimony that she did not sign the 1998             
          return is inconsistent with the parties’ stipulation that she did           






Page:  Previous  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011