Carrie H. Suchar, Transferee, et al. - Page 25

                                       - 25 -                                         
               With regard to consideration Richard received in connection            
          with the September 1998 transfer of his one-half interest in the            
          farm acreage, Marilou paid off Richard’s liability under the                
          divorce decree on $15,892 of mortgage debt and real estate taxes,           
          for which $15,892 of consideration Richard is to receive credit.            
               We emphasize that the obligation Richard had under the                 
          divorce decree to Marilou was based on the anticipated sale by              
          Richard of the entire property or on a transfer to Richard of               
          Marilou’s one-half ownership interests in the farm acreage and in           
          the residence acreage.  Since Richard never received Marilou’s              
          interests and since Marilou herself participated in the transfers           
          of her interests therein to other individuals, Richard’s                    
          obligations to Marilou under the divorce decree may be seen to              
          have been extinguished as a result of the transfers at issue in             
          this case.  But such extinguishment is not properly regarded as             
          consideration that Richard received for the transfer of his one-            
          half ownership interests in the farm acreage and in the residence           
          acreage.  Rather, as stated, to the extent such extinguishment              
          occurred here, it did so because Richard never received Marilou’s           
          ownership interests and because Marilou herself transferred her             
          interests in the properties.                                                
               Petitioners argue that the September 9, 1998, transfers by             
          Richard and Marilou of the residence acreage to Marilou and                 
          Carrie and of the farm acreage to Carrie, Tracy, and Deborah                






Page:  Previous  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011