James T. and Rebecca S. Werther - Page 4

                                        - 3 -                                         
          initiated by petitioner.2  On September 20, 1994, Eileen and                
          petitioner entered into a final separation agreement covering               
          matters that were not addressed by the Louisiana order.  Also on            
          September 20, 1994, a hearing was conducted before the Chittenden           
          Family Court, Chittenden County, State of Vermont.  On October              
          12, 1994, the Chittenden Family Court entered a final order,                
          which incorporated matters covered in the final separation                  
          agreement.  Paragraph 1 of the final order provided:                        
               [Eileen] shall have the legal and physical parental rights             
               and responsibilities of the parties’ following minor                   
               children:  (a) [JW], (b) [RW], (c) [MW].                               
          Paragraph 18 of the final order provided:                                   
               In future years [after 1993], the parties shall allocate the           
               children for dependency purposes in such manner as most                
               reduces the overall tax burden of both parties, provided,              
               however, that if Plaintiff [Eileen] incurs a greater tax               
               liability than if she were to claim the three youngest                 
               children as dependents, Defendant [petitioner] shall make up           
               the difference to Plaintiff [Eileen] and pay her by April              
               15th of that year.                                                     
               On or about April 3, 2002, petitioners filed their Form                
          1040, U.S. Individual Income Tax Return, for the 2001 taxable               
          year.  In their return, petitioners claimed RW and MW as their              
          dependents and claimed the resulting exemption deductions, as               
          well as a $600 child tax credit.  There was no attachment                   
          regarding any waiver or declaration, such as a Form 8332, Release           
          of Claim to Exemption for Child of Divorced or Separated Parents,           


          2After his divorce from Eileen, petitioner married Rebecca                  
          S. Werther (petitioner wife).                                               




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011