Joseph Orlando Beckford - Page 5

                                        - 4 -                                         
          Petitioner explained that he lacked documentation because he                
          generally paid TW’s expenses in cash.                                       
               Petitioner and Ms. Blake shared the expenses for support of            
          the household.  According to petitioner, he “helped with” paying            
          the mortgage, the utilities, and “most of everything”.  The                 
          record is unclear as to the amount of expenses paid for the                 
          household.  It is also unclear how petitioner and Ms. Blake                 
          allocated the expenses between them.  It appears that petitioner            
          contributed to the household expenses whenever he was able and              
          that he did not pay a set amount to Ms. Blake.  The Court is                
          unable to determine how much of the expenses paid by petitioner             
          related to TW.                                                              
               TW attended private school and her tuition was approximately           
          $287 per month.  Ms. Blake testified that both she and petitioner           
          together paid TW’s tuition.  Petitioner, however, failed to offer           
          any records or receipts from the school to show the amount of               
          TW’s expenses or how those expenses were paid and allocated.                
               Ms. Blake, by her own admission, earned about three times as           
          much as petitioner in 2003.  The Court concludes that petitioner            
          has not offered sufficient evidence to show that he provided more           
          than half of TW’s support in 2003.                                          











Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011